GGoodDock

GoodDock Blog

VA Higher Level Review Informal Conference Script: What to Say

A VA higher level review informal conference script sounds formal. The call is not. It is a 15 to 20 minute phone call with a senior reviewer who reads your file fresh and looks for mistakes in the first decision. No new evidence is allowed. That limit shapes everything you say.

Your job on the call is narrow: point to specific errors, name the page or document that proves it, and ask for the fix. Stories help only when they point to a document. Keep it tight.

Open with your claim number and the decision date, name one error at a time, point to the exact document that shows it, and ask the reviewer to note it. Duty to assist errors, missed records, and wrong effective dates are the strongest points. Close by asking what happens next and when.

Prepare one page before the call

Write one page and keep it in front of you during the call. List the decision date, the issues on appeal, and up to three errors, each with the document name and date that proves it. Three strong errors beat ten vague complaints. Reviewers remember specifics.

Check the decision letter line by line first. Mark every place where the letter says a record was not received, a exam was not considered, or a date looks wrong. Those marks become your talking points. Guesswork stays off the page.

  • Decision date and claim number at the top of the page.
  • Up to three errors, ranked strongest first.
  • For each error: the document name, its date, and one line on what it shows.
  • A short note on what outcome you are asking for on each issue.
  • Pen ready: write down the reviewer name and anything promised.

Open the call in 60 seconds

Start with the facts, not the backstory. Say your name, your claim number, and that you requested this conference to point out errors in the decision dated on your letter. Then say how many points you have. That frame helps the reviewer take notes in order.

A sample open sounds like this: thank you for the call, my claim number is on file, and I have three errors to point out in the decision. Short. Calm. No anger, even if the first decision frustrated you. Reviewers listen longer to calm callers.

  1. Thank the reviewer and confirm your identity.
  2. State the decision date you are appealing.
  3. Say how many errors you will raise.
  4. Start with the strongest error, not the longest story.

Name duty to assist errors clearly

A duty to assist error means VA had a duty to get a record or an exam and did not. Common examples: a private treatment record listed in your file was never requested, or an exam was ordered but the report never arrived. These errors matter because they can send the claim back for the missing step.

Point to the proof, not the feeling. Say the record name, the date you listed it, and where it appears in the file. Then ask the reviewer to note the missing step. If you are not sure a duty to assist error applies, say so plainly and ask the reviewer to check that point.

  • Missing records: name the clinic, the dates of treatment, and where you listed it.
  • Missing exams: note the exam VA ordered and what never came back.
  • Wrong standard: note where the decision used the wrong test for your issue.
  • Keep each point under a minute. Long points lose the thread.

Ask about effective dates and extras

After errors, check the dates. An effective date decides when back pay starts, and a wrong date costs real money. If the decision granted something but used a later date than your original claim, raise it on the call and name the earlier filing date.

Also ask whether any issue was left out of the decision. Claims sometimes drop an issue between filings. Naming a missing issue on the call is easier than filing a new claim later. Write down the answer for each point before you hang up.

  • Effective date: compare the granted date to your original filing date.
  • Missing issues: list any condition from your claim that the decision never addressed.
  • Rating math: note any combined rating that looks off and ask for a check.
  • Ask what happens next and the rough timeline, then write it down.

Close the call and write it down

Close by repeating the points back in one sentence each. Ask the reviewer to confirm they noted each error. Then ask what happens next: a new decision, a return for more development, or a denial that keeps your appeal rights. Get the sequence right before you hang up.

Within an hour, write a short note of the call: date, reviewer name if given, points raised, and answers received. File it with your claim papers. Memory fades. Paper does not.

This is general information, not legal advice. I turned this into a free printable conference prep sheet — get the free sample. It pairs with the 48-page claim organizer, which tracks evidence, deadlines, and the three appeal lanes in one place.

Can I submit new evidence during an informal conference?

No, the higher level review lane is closed to new evidence, and the reviewer decides only on the file as it stood at the first decision. Use the call to point out errors in how that file was read. If you have new evidence, the supplemental claim lane is the route that accepts it.

How long does a VA informal conference usually last?

Most informal conferences last 15 to 20 minutes, though some run shorter when the points are clear. Prepare up to three errors and keep each point under a minute so the call stays on track. A short, organized call usually gets more noted than a long, wandering one.

What if I miss my scheduled informal conference call?

If you miss the call, the reviewer usually decides the higher level review on the written record alone, without your input. Contact VA promptly through the number on your decision letter to explain and ask about options. Keep a note of who you spoke with and what they said.

Does an informal conference change my appeal deadline?

No, the informal conference sits inside the higher level review you already filed, so it does not reset other deadlines. Watch the decision that follows the conference for its own appeal window, usually one year. Mark that date on your calendar the day the letter arrives.