Never sign at the meeting
A severance package checklist (printable, one page) belongs in your hands before you sign anything - because the agreement HR slides across the table was written to protect the company, not you. You almost always have days or weeks to review it. Take every one of them.
Here is the part most people miss: severance is negotiable. Not every line, not always - but the payout amount, the health coverage duration, and the non-compete land on the table more often than HR implies. The checklist below walks the math and the clauses in order.
Take the full review period - never sign at the meeting. Check the payout math, gross versus net after taxes, and read the release of claims and non-compete line by line. Ask about extending health coverage beyond COBRA. If you are over 40, federal law gives you 21 days to consider and 7 days to revoke after signing. Negotiate the money and the coverage first.
The 6-line review checklist
Work through these in order. Each one has tripped up someone who signed too fast. Print the list, grab a highlighter, and go line by line against your actual agreement - never from memory:
- Gross payout math. Weeks of pay times weekly salary, plus unused PTO payout and any prorated bonus. Get the number in writing.
- The tax hit. Severance is taxed as ordinary income, usually withheld at the 22% federal supplemental rate. Your actual bill may be higher at filing time.
- Release of claims. You are waiving the right to sue the company. Make sure what you're getting is worth what you're giving up.
- Non-compete and non-solicit. How long, how broad, which states. Some states won't enforce these at all - know yours.
- Health coverage. Compare extended employer-paid months against COBRA, which often runs $700 or more a month for single coverage.
- Reference terms. Get in writing what the company will say when a future employer calls. Verbal promises evaporate.
Negotiable vs. fixed: what's actually on the table
Knowing which is which keeps you from wasting effort on fixed items while leaving real money on the table:
| Usually negotiable | Usually fixed |
|---|---|
| Severance amount (weeks of pay) | The decision to lay you off |
| COBRA subsidy or extended coverage | State unemployment eligibility rules |
| Non-compete scope and duration | Accrued PTO payout (set by state law) |
| Outplacement services | 401(k) vesting schedule |
| Last day / garden-leave dates | Tax treatment of the payout |
The email that starts the negotiation
You don't negotiate severance across a conference table. You do it in a short, professional email after you've reviewed everything. The structure that works: thank them for the package, name the two or three specific items you'd like adjusted, and give a one-line reason for each. 'I'd like to discuss extending the health coverage from 3 months to 6, given my surgery scheduled in February' beats 'I want more money' every single time.
Keep it to 150 words. Attach nothing. End with a clear ask for a call to discuss. HR expects a counter - silence reads as acceptance. One more rule: negotiate the money and the coverage first, the nice-to-haves second. And never threaten to sue in the email; that moves your file to legal and freezes everything solid. Knowing how to review severance agreement terms is only half the battle; the other half is asking, in writing, for what it's worth.
The money math people get wrong
Three miscalculations show up in almost every rushed signing:
- That $40,000 severance isn't $40,000. Taxes take their cut first. Budget on the net number, not the headline.
- COBRA sticker shock. Employer coverage felt free; COBRA bills you the full premium plus an admin fee. Price it before you need it.
- Unemployment plus severance. Some states reduce unemployment benefits while severance is being paid out. Check your state's rule before you file.
- The forgotten 401(k) loan. Outstanding loans often become due within 60 days of separation - unpaid balances get taxed as distributions.
Use the 10-day rule
Even when the agreement allows three weeks, set your own deadline: decide within 10 days. Long enough to get an employment lawyer's review (many do flat-fee severance reviews), short enough that you don't ruminate for a month. Negotiate in writing - email, not hallway chats - and keep copies of every version.
One more thing: the review itself can pay for itself. A single changed clause - three extra months of health coverage, a narrowed non-compete - is often worth five figures. The lawyers who do flat-fee severance reviews see the same five mistakes every week; you're buying pattern recognition, not hours.
One tactic that consistently works: ask for the non-cash items first. Extended health coverage, outplacement coaching, and a later official end date cost the company less than cash but matter enormously to you. Then negotiate the payout amount with the goodwill you've built. Get the final agreement in writing before your last day - verbal promises from a manager who's also leaving are worth nothing.
I turned this into a free printable severance package checklist - get the free checklist. It sits inside the 56-page SteadyPath Layoff Survival Binder, alongside the full 15-item Day-Zero review and the 30-day job search plan.
This is general information, not professional advice. Employment law varies by state - talk to a licensed attorney in yours.
How long do I have to sign a severance agreement?
Under the federal Older Workers Benefit Protection Act, employees 40 and older get 21 days to consider the agreement and 7 days to revoke after signing. For everyone else, the deadline is whatever the agreement states - often 7 to 21 days. Never let HR rush you past the written deadline.
Is severance pay taxed?
Yes. Severance is taxed as ordinary income, and employers usually withhold federal tax at the 22% supplemental wage rate. Depending on your bracket and state taxes, you may owe more when you file - so budget on the net number, not the gross headline.
Can I negotiate my severance package?
Often, yes. The payout amount, extended health coverage, non-compete scope, outplacement services, and the official last day are all commonly negotiated. Put requests in writing, keep the tone professional, and know your walk-away point before the conversation starts. A short consultation with an employment lawyer sharpens the ask.
Should I sign a non-compete in a severance agreement?
It depends on your state - several states ban or sharply limit non-competes, and courts elsewhere weigh duration and geographic scope. Have an employment lawyer review the clause before you sign, and try to narrow anything broader than 6 to 12 months. This is general information, not professional advice.