A nanny reference call takes twelve minutes. A bad hire costs you six months of mornings you dread. Most parents ask five friendly questions, hear five friendly answers, and learn nothing. These nanny reference questions, printable, grouped, and scoreable, fix the laziest part of hiring: thirty specific questions across four areas, with a scoring system that turns polite chatter into comparable data.
Call three references per finalist. Ask every reference the same questions to ask nanny references from the list below. Score as you go, the pattern across three calls tells you more than any single glowing review.
Ask 30 nanny reference questions on every call: 7 on reliability, 8 on childcare skills, 8 on safety and judgment, and 7 designed to surface red flags. Call three references per finalist, ask the same questions each time, and score answers 1 to 3. Consistent scores across references predict the hire; a single glowing outlier does not.
Reliability: 7 questions
Reliability is the trait parents undervalue and regret most. A brilliant nanny who cancels twice a month will wreck your work calendar. These seven questions pin down punctuality, attendance, and follow-through, the stuff that only shows up after week three.
- How often was she late, honestly? Follow up: was it a pattern or one rough month?
- How many sick days or last-minute cancellations in a typical year?
- Did she follow your household rules when you weren't watching, screen time limits, bedtime, food rules?
- When plans changed mid-day, how did she handle it?
- Would you trust her with your house keys and alarm code again tomorrow?
- Did she ever leave early or cut corners you only found out about later?
- How much notice did she give before leaving the job?
Childcare skills: 8 questions
This is the section most question lists skip in favor of vibes. Don't. Ask for specifics, what the nanny actually did all day, and how the kids responded over time.
- Describe a typical day with her. What did the kids actually do?
- How did she handle tantrums or sibling fights? Give me one example.
- Did your kids run to her, or just tolerate her? There is a difference, and it matters.
- How did she handle meals, picky eaters, allergies, cooking from scratch?
- What was she like with routines: naps, homework, bedtime wind-down?
- Did the kids pick up anything new with her, words, skills, habits?
- How did she communicate with you during the day? Texts, photos, a written log?
- What would you call her single strongest skill with children?
Safety and judgment: 8 questions
Nobody volunteers safety concerns unprompted. You have to ask directly, in a way that makes honesty easy. Frame it as routine: I ask every reference these.
- Was there ever a safety incident, a fall, a scare, a close call? How did she respond in the moment?
- Did she drive with the kids? How was her driving, honestly?
- How careful was she with allergies, medications, and choking hazards?
- Did she ever have her phone out when she should have been watching?
- How did she handle strangers, at the park, at the front door?
- Was she trained in infant or child CPR and first aid while with you?
- Did you ever worry, even briefly, about her judgment?
- Would you leave a newborn with her? A toddler? Where is your line?
Red flags: 7 questions that surface what references won't volunteer
References are usually friendly, which is exactly why you need questions engineered for the uncomfortable stuff. Ask these last, when the conversation is warm and guards are down.
- Why did the arrangement really end?
- Is there anything you wish you'd known in the first month?
- Did you ever feel you couldn't be fully honest with her about something?
- How did she take feedback or criticism?
- Was there ever a money disagreement, hours, overtime, raises?
- Would you hire her again if your kids were the same age today?
- Is there anyone else I should talk to about her?
Score it in ten minutes
Thirty questions are useless without a way to compare answers. Keep it simple: score each answer 1 to 3 as you listen, 1 for vague or evasive, 2 for solid, 3 for specific and enthusiastic. Total each candidate's three reference calls out of 270.
The number matters less than the pattern. A candidate who scores steady 2s across all three references is a safer hire than one with a single glowing call and two lukewarm ones. **Consistency predicts; charm doesn't.
Two finalists with close scores? Pick the one whose worst reference was still solid. Floors matter more than ceilings.**
I turned this into a free printable nanny reference check template, get the free checklist. It comes from the 56-page Nanny Hiring & Management Kit, which also includes 43 interview questions, a trial-day scorecard, and 10 annotated work agreement sections.
How many references should I call for a nanny?
Three per finalist, minimum. One reference can be a fluke, friendly, loyal, or just conflict-avoidant. Three calls let you compare patterns: if all three mention great mornings but vague discipline, you've found the real picture. Ask every reference the same 30 questions so the answers are actually comparable.
What if a nanny candidate has no references?
Treat it as a yellow flag, not a dealbreaker, but verify another way. Ask for a paid trial week with close supervision, request character references from non-family employers, and run the background check before day one. First-time nannies exist; unvetted ones shouldn't.
Can I ask a reference about discipline style?
Yes, and you should. Ask for a specific example: tell me about a time she had to set a firm boundary. Vague answers like she was great with discipline tell you nothing. You're listening for alignment with your own approach, a strict household and a permissive nanny will clash within a month.
What is the biggest red flag on a nanny reference call?
Hesitation. When a reference pauses, hedges, or says she was fine three different ways, they're telling you something without saying it. Follow up gently: it sounds like there might be more there, I ask because I want the full picture. The second answer is usually the honest one.