GGoodDock

GoodDock Blog

Nanny Payroll Tax Checklist: What Families Owe the IRS

You hired a nanny, not a payroll department. Then someone mentions the "nanny tax," and suddenly you're an employer with IRS forms due and no idea where to start.

This nanny payroll tax checklist walks through the three federal taxes, the 2026 dollar thresholds that trigger them, and the exact forms to file. Plain English, no accounting background required.

For 2026, pay a household employee $3,000 or more in a calendar year and you owe Social Security and Medicare taxes: 15.3% total, split evenly at 7.65% each. Pay $1,000 in total household wages in any quarter and federal unemployment tax applies too. You report everything on Schedule H with your personal tax return. Get an EIN before you run payroll, withhold 7.65% FICA once you cross $3,000, and file Schedule H in April.

First, the uncomfortable truth: your nanny is your employee

If you decide what your nanny does and how she does it, the schedule, the routines, the rules, the IRS classifies her as your household employee. Calling her a contractor on a 1099 doesn't change that, and the IRS looks closely at household arrangements. These household employer tax requirements apply whether you hired through an agency referral, a friend, or a Facebook group.

Two exceptions matter. If an agency employs the nanny and controls the work, she's the agency's employee, not yours. And if your worker is under 18 and school, not household work, is their main occupation, their wages are exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes. The weekend babysitter who's a high school student usually qualifies. Your full-time nanny doesn't.

Tax #1: the $3,000 trigger and the 15.3% split

In 2026, once you pay one household employee $3,000 or more in cash wages for the year, Social Security and Medicare taxes kick in on all of it, not just the amount above $3,000. That's the nanny tax threshold 2026 sets, and the combined rate is 15.3%: you withhold 6.2% Social Security plus 1.45% Medicare from your nanny's pay, then match it dollar for dollar from your own pocket.

The threshold is per employee, not per household. Pay two sitters $2,500 each and neither triggers it; pay one nanny $3,000 and you owe FICA on her wages. Non-cash perks like meals don't count toward the threshold. Only cash wages do.

Tax #2: the FUTA surprise almost everyone misses

Separate from FICA, federal unemployment tax (FUTA) kicks in if you pay $1,000 or more in total cash wages to all your household employees combined in any single calendar quarter. Plenty of families clear this without realizing it.

The rate is 6% on the first $7,000 of each employee's yearly wages, but if you pay into your state's unemployment fund, which nearly every state requires, you get a credit that drops the effective federal rate to 0.6%. That works out to a maximum of about $42 per employee per year. Small, but the penalties for ignoring it aren't.

The three federal taxes at a glance

Pin this to the fridge. These are the only three federal obligations most household employers face.

Print it. Keep it with your tax folder.

TaxTriggers when (2026)RateWho pays
Social Security + Medicare (FICA)$3,000+ to one employee in the year15.3% (7.65% each)Split: you withhold half, match half
Federal unemployment (FUTA)$1,000+ total household wages in any quarter6% on first $7,000 (0.6% effective)You, the employer
Federal income tax withholdingOnly if you and your nanny agreePer Form W-4Withheld from nanny's pay

The paperwork: EIN, Schedule H, W-2

Six steps, roughly in order. None of them is hard. The pain comes from discovering them in April.

  1. Get an employer ID number (EIN) from the IRS. Free, online, takes minutes.
  2. Have your nanny complete Form W-4 and Form I-9 for work eligibility.
  3. Withhold 7.65% FICA from each paycheck once you cross $3,000.
  4. Register for and pay any state unemployment insurance your state requires. Most do.
  5. Give your nanny a W-2 by January 31.
  6. File Schedule H with your Form 1040 in April and pay what's owed.

Four mistakes that cost families real money

The IRS doesn't expect perfection from first-time household employers. It does expect a good-faith effort, and these four errors are where good faith usually breaks down.

  • Treating the nanny as an independent contractor to skip payroll taxes. The control test decides, not the label.
  • Paying cash under the table and "sorting it out later." Later comes with penalties and interest.
  • Missing the January 31 W-2 deadline. Late forms draw fines per form.
  • Forgetting state requirements: most states want their own unemployment registration and withholding filings.

When to stop doing this yourself

If the forms make your eyes glaze over, that's what nanny payroll services are for. They run payroll, file quarterly, and handle year-end forms for a monthly fee. Compare that fee against one penalty notice and the math usually decides itself.

I turned this into a free printable nanny payroll tax checklist — get the free checklist. It's a sample from the 56-page Nanny Hiring & Management Kit, which includes 43 interview questions, 5 Excel workbook sheets, and 10 annotated work-agreement sections.

This is general information, not professional advice. Thresholds adjust yearly, so confirm current figures in IRS Publication 926 or with a CPA.

Do I owe nanny tax if I pay my sitter less than $3,000 a year?

You won't owe Social Security and Medicare taxes below the $3,000 per-employee threshold, but you're not automatically off the hook. FUTA can still apply if your total household wages hit $1,000 in any quarter, and your state may have its own registration and filing requirements with lower thresholds. Check your state's labor department site before assuming you're clear.

Can I just call my nanny an independent contractor?

No. The label doesn't decide; the working relationship does. If you control the nanny's schedule, duties, and methods, she's your employee under the IRS control test, whether you issue a W-2 or a 1099. Misclassification can trigger back taxes, penalties, and interest. Real contractors set their own methods and work for multiple clients; a nanny following your daily routine doesn't fit.

Do I have to withhold federal income tax from my nanny's pay?

Not unless you both agree to it. Unlike FICA, federal income tax withholding is optional for household employees, but your nanny still owes income tax on the wages, so many families withhold by agreement to save her an April surprise. Either way, report the wages on her W-2 and remind her to plan for it.

What if I've been paying cash for months without filing?

Fix it going forward and clean up the past. The IRS treats voluntary correction far better than getting caught. Get an EIN, start withholding now, and file Schedule H for the tax year in question, reporting all wages paid. You'll owe the taxes plus potential penalties and interest, but coming forward stops the clock. A CPA can help you file correctly the first time.