Nannies rarely quit over one bad week. They quit over a year of extra duties, extra hours, and the same pay. A nanny pay raise review checklist fixes that drift before it becomes a resignation. Review pay on a schedule, check the market rate, and say the new number out loud in a real conversation. Silence reads as indifference. A scheduled review reads as respect.
This checklist covers timing, the market check, the raise math, and the conversation itself. Run it once a year, and again whenever duties change. A raise given on time costs less than a search for a replacement.
Review pay every 12 months and whenever duties grow, check the local market rate for the same hours and duties, and raise pay in writing with the new rate and start date. A scheduled review keeps a good nanny from quietly job hunting.
Review on schedule, and when duties grow
Annual reviews work because they are predictable. A nanny who knows a review comes every 12 months can wait for it. A nanny who hears nothing for two years starts to assume nothing is coming. Mark the hire date and set a reminder 30 days before each anniversary. That month gives you time to check rates, review duties, and plan the conversation without rushing it.
Duties change faster than anniversaries. A second child, a new school run, homework help that was not in the original agreement, or a schedule that crept from 40 hours to 48 all justify a mid-year review. Track duties as they change. A short note each time duties grow becomes the raise case later. Memory fades. Notes hold up.
- Annual date set: hire-date anniversary, with a reminder 30 days before.
- Duty changes logged: new children, new tasks, and extra hours noted as they happen.
- Hours tracked: a creep from 40 to 48 hours is a raise case on its own.
- Mid-year trigger: any major duty change earns a review, not a wait until next year.
Check the market before you name a number
Fair pay starts with the local market, not with what you paid last year. Ask local nanny agencies, parent groups, and job boards what nannies with the same hours, duties, and experience earn in your area. Rates move with demand, and a rate that was fair two years ago can sit well below today's market. A nanny who discovers that gap from a job ad will not wait for your review to catch up.
Compare like with like. A nanny who cooks, drives, and tutors earns more than one who watches one child at home. Years of experience, certifications, and extra skills like a second language all count. Write down three comparable rates and your nanny's duties beside them. That page is your raise math, and it keeps the conversation honest for both sides.
- Three local rates: same hours, same duties, same experience level.
- Duties matched: cooking, driving, and tutoring each add to the rate.
- Experience counted: years in the role and relevant certifications matter.
- Gap named plainly: if the market moved, say so, and close the gap.
Build the raise, then write it down
Raise math has three parts: market catch-up, a cost-of-living bump, and a merit piece for strong performance. A common shape is a market adjustment to the local rate plus 2 to 4 percent for another year of good work. If duties grew, add a duty amount on top. Keep the parts separate when you explain them. A nanny who hears 'market plus merit' understands the raise. A nanny who hears one lump number wonders what it covers.
Put the new rate in writing the same day, with the start date, the hours, and any duty changes. Update the work agreement at the same time. Verbal raises get forgotten, and forgotten raises become arguments. A one-page amendment beats a memory. Sign it. File it. Both sides keep a copy.
- Market catch-up first: bring pay to the current local rate for the role.
- Merit on top: 2 to 4 percent for another year of strong work.
- Duty amount added: extra children or tasks get their own line.
- Written amendment: new rate, start date, hours, and duties, signed by both sides.
Hold the conversation in person
Hold the conversation in person, not by text, and lead with appreciation that names specifics. 'The school run you added in March, and the homework routine you built' lands better than 'you're great.' Then name the new rate, the reasons in one sentence each, and the start date. Pause. Let her respond. A review is a conversation, not an announcement, and a nanny who can speak honestly in it will stay honest about problems later.
If you cannot afford the full market rate, say so plainly and offer what you can: a smaller raise now with a dated second step, extra paid days off, or a schedule change she values. Honesty keeps trust. A vague promise does not. End with the next review date, written down. A raise with a next date is a system. A raise alone is a one-time event.
I turned this into a free printable pay raise review checklist — get the free checklist. It holds the timing, market check, and raise math from the 56-page kit, so the review conversation starts from a page, not a guess.
How often should nanny pay be reviewed?
Once a year, on the hire-date anniversary, and again whenever duties grow in a major way. A second child, a new school run, or hours creeping past the original schedule all justify a mid-year review. A predictable annual date lets a nanny wait for the review instead of job hunting.
How much of a raise should a nanny get?
Start by matching the current local market rate for the same hours and duties, then add 2 to 4 percent for another year of strong work. If duties grew, add a separate duty amount. Keep the parts distinct when you explain the raise so the nanny sees what each piece covers.
Should a nanny raise be put in writing?
Yes, the same day. Write the new rate, the start date, the hours, and any duty changes in a one-page amendment to the work agreement, signed by both sides. Verbal raises get forgotten and become arguments, while a signed page protects both the family and the nanny.
What if we cannot afford the full market rate?
Say so plainly and offer what you can: a smaller raise now with a dated second step, extra paid days off, or a schedule change the nanny values. Honesty keeps trust, and a dated next step turns a partial raise into a plan rather than a vague promise.