Hiring a nanny is weird. You're inviting a stranger into your home and handing them your kids — and a 45-minute chat is supposed to tell you if it's safe.
It can, if you ask the right nanny interview questions. The ones below are organized by what actually causes nanny relationships to fail: logistics, discipline mismatches, and money awkwardness nobody addressed upfront. Print them out. Take notes. Compare candidates side by side.
Start with a phone screen
Don't burn a Saturday on in-person interviews yet. A 15-minute phone call filters out half your candidates.
Ask three things: availability and schedule fit, rate range, and why they left their last family. If the schedule doesn't work or the rate is double your budget, you've saved everyone an hour. Also listen for how they talk about the last family — gracious beats gossipy, every time.
Invite your top 3–4 to meet in person. No more. Interview fatigue makes every candidate blur together.
One more filter: ask what ages they've worked with most. A brilliant infant nanny and a brilliant after-school nanny are different skill sets. Match the experience to your kids' ages, not just the resume.
Daily routines and logistics
Start with the boring stuff. Most nanny mismatches are logistics, not personality.
- Walk me through a typical day with a two-year-old. Listen for structure — meals, naps, outdoor time. Vague answers are a flag.
- What's your sick-day backup plan? Everyone gets sick. You need the answer before it happens, not during.
- How do you handle screen time? Get a specific number of minutes, not a philosophy.
- Are you comfortable with kid-related housework — bottles, kids' laundry, toy cleanup? Define it now.
- How do you track what happened during the day? Daily log, texts, app — pick one and stick with it.
- What's your approach to outings — parks, library, playdates? And are you comfortable driving with the kids?
- How do you handle nap transitions when a child fights sleep? This reveals patience better than any hypothetical.
Discipline, safety, and the hard scenarios
This is where you find out whether your parenting styles can coexist. Don't skip it because it feels confrontational.
- How do you handle a full tantrum in a grocery store? You want calm and specific, not theoretical.
- What would you do if my child got hurt while you glanced away? Honesty beats perfection here.
- Are you CPR and first-aid certified? If not, would you get certified before starting? Non-negotiable for infants.
- How do you feel about our house rules on food, bedtime, and visitors? Bring your actual rules to the interview.
- Have you ever had a serious disagreement with a parent? What happened? Everyone has a story. Listen to how they tell it.
- What would you do if you disagreed with a parenting decision I made? You're hiring judgment, not obedience — but you need to know where the line is.
- How do you handle sibling fights? If you have more than one kid, this isn't hypothetical.
Pay, schedule, and the awkward money talk
Get the money talk done in the interview, not over text two weeks in. Awkward now beats resentful later.
- What are your rate expectations, and how do you calculate overtime? Get numbers, not ranges.
- How should paid time off, holidays, and sick days work? Whatever you agree, put it in writing.
- Do you expect guaranteed hours if we go on vacation? This one surprises a lot of first-time parents. Ask it.
- How do you want to handle raises and annual reviews? A nanny who never asks is a nanny who quietly quits.
- Are you looking for a long-term position or filling a gap? Mismatched timelines are nobody's fault, but they hurt when discovered late.
How to check references (actually do it)
Most parents collect references and never call. Don't be most parents. A 10-minute call beats another interview.
Ask references: How long did she work for you, and why did it end? What was a typical day like? How did she handle discipline — give me one specific example. Would you hire her again? That last question tells you everything — hesitation is an answer.
Also ask what surprised them, good or bad. 'She was amazing with the baby but always 10 minutes late' is useful data, not a dealbreaker — unless punctuality is your dealbreaker. Write down what you hear. Memory lies; notes don't.
Get the printable version
I turned this into a free printable checklist — get the free nanny interview questions list. It comes from the 56-page Nanny Hiring & Management Kit, which also includes the 43-question master bank, 10 annotated contract sections, and a trial-period tracker most families wish they'd had from day one.
Bring the printout. Check things off. Score candidates on the same questions. That's the whole point — fair comparisons, no gut-feel hiring.
How many questions should I ask in a nanny interview?
Plan 15 to 20 questions across 45 minutes. More feels like an interrogation; fewer means you're hiring on vibes. Use a printed checklist so every candidate gets the same questions — it's the only way to compare fairly.
Should I do a trial day before hiring a nanny?
Yes — a paid trial day tells you more than three interviews. Watch how they handle a meal or nap transition, whether they clean up without being asked, and how your kids respond when you're not in the room. Pay them for the day; good candidates expect it.
What are red flags in a nanny interview?
Vague answers about daily routines, reluctance to provide references, zero questions for you, and visible discomfort discussing pay. Also trust your gut — a bad feeling at minute 45 doesn't improve at hour 400.
Do I need a written contract with my nanny?
Absolutely. Cover rate, hours, overtime, PTO, sick days, and termination terms before day one. It prevents nearly every common dispute. Don't start from a blank page — use a template and adapt it to your family's specifics.