GGoodDock

GoodDock Blog

How to Hire a Nanny: Step by Step From Search to Day One

Hiring a nanny is the first time most parents become employers, tax forms and contracts included. Learning how to hire a nanny step by step matters because a rushed hire costs you months of turnover and a toddler who has to bond all over again.

The nanny hiring process below is the one that works: define the job, source carefully, interview consistently, check backgrounds, trial, then write it down. Skip a step and it finds you later.

Write the job description before you post anything: hours, pay, duties. Interview 3 to 4 candidates with the same questions, run background and reference checks, then do a paid trial day before offering the job. Put pay, hours, sick days, and PTO in a written agreement before day one. That sequence prevents most hiring regrets.

Step 1: Write the Job Before You Post It

Most bad hires start with a vague post. Write down exact hours, start date, pay range, duties (and non-duties: laundry? cooking?), driving needs, and deal-breakers like screen-time rules before you talk to anyone. Candidates self-select out, and interviews stay comparable.

  • Exact hours and schedule, including early/late flexibility expectations.
  • Pay range, posted upfront. It filters for fit faster than anything else.
  • Duties vs non-duties. Child-related laundry, yes? Family cooking, no? Say so.
  • Must-haves: CPR certification, driving, experience with your child's age group.

Where to Find Candidates Worth Interviewing

Where you look determines who you meet. Every source has a trade-off, so use two at once.

A referral from a family whose kids are similar ages to yours is worth ten anonymous applications. Ask what the nanny was actually like on hard days, not just whether they would rehire her. Everyone says they would rehire. The details tell you whether you want the same experience.

  • Parent referrals are the gold standard. A nanny a trusted friend used for two years beats any ad.
  • Agencies do the legwork (screening, background checks) and charge for it, often a month of salary or a flat fee.
  • Care platforms give you volume. You do all the vetting yourself, so budget the time.
  • Your pediatrician and parent groups hear who is great and who just became available. Ask around before you post.
Where you lookCostYour effortBest for
Parent referralsFreeLowWarm leads you can trust
AgenciesOften a month of salary or a flat feeLowHands-off screening and vetting
Care platformsSmall membership or freeHigh (you vet everyone)Maximum choice
Pediatrician and parent groupsFreeLowUnder-the-radar great candidates

Interview 3 to 4 Candidates the Same Way

Same questions, every candidate, scored on the same sheet. That is the whole secret. Memory lies; scorecards do not. Aim for three to four finalists: fewer and you have no comparison, more and decision fatigue sets in.

  • Daily routine: Walk me through a day with a two-year-old (use your child's age).
  • Discipline: What do you do when a child hits, bites, or melts down in public?
  • Safety: Choking response, water rules, allergy protocols. Listen for specifics, not vibes.
  • Sick-child policy: When do you call in, and what backup care do you expect us to have?
  • Communication: How will I hear about my child's day? Photos? A log? A quick chat?
  • History: Why did you leave your last family? Then verify it with the reference.

Check Backgrounds Like an Employer

You are hiring someone to be alone with your child. Verify everything, warmly and without apology. Good candidates expect it.

  • Criminal background check, with written consent. Non-negotiable.
  • Driving record if she will drive your kids. One check, five minutes.
  • Two to three references, by phone. Ask what a typical day looked like and why the arrangement ended.
  • Verify CPR and first aid certifications are current, not just claimed.

The Paid Trial Day

A half day with you home but hands-off shows you more than three interviews combined. Pay her normal hourly rate for it. Candidates who refuse a trial are telling you something.

Structure the trial loosely: morning routine, a meal, an outing or activity, nap or quiet time. You are watching for warmth under mild stress, not a performance. The right candidate will be a little nervous and completely natural with your child within the hour.

  • Watch the interaction, not perfection. Warmth, patience, and getting on the floor matter more than a perfect schedule.
  • Note how she handles crying and boredom. Those are the real job.
  • See how your child responds. Comfort within an hour is a good sign; clinging to you the whole time is information too.
  • Debrief the same day. Specific observations beat gut feelings when you compare finalists.

Put It in Writing Before Day One

Most nanny disputes come from handshake deals where each side remembers it differently. A simple written agreement prevents nearly all of them.

  • Pay rate, pay schedule, and overtime rules. State the hourly rate and when overtime kicks in.
  • Schedule and guaranteed hours. If you do not need her one week, does she still get paid? Decide now.
  • PTO, sick days, and paid holidays. Spell out the numbers, not just the categories.
  • Taxes. In the U.S. you are generally a household employer: Social Security and Medicare taxes apply. Check IRS Publication 926 or use a payroll service.
  • Trial period terms. Thirty to ninety days where either side can end it cleanly.
  • How either side ends the arrangement. Notice period, severance if any, and final-pay timing.

Get the Free Nanny Hiring Checklist

I turned this into a free printable nanny hiring checklist. Get the free checklist.

The Nanny Hiring and Management Kit includes 56 printable pages, the full 43-question interview bank, and 10 annotated agreement sections so the paperwork writes itself.

This is general information, not professional advice. Household-employer tax rules and background-check consent requirements vary by state: verify the current thresholds with the IRS or a payroll service before you hire.

How much does a nanny cost?

It varies widely by city, hours, and experience, so interview several candidates to learn your local market before you set a range. Full-time infant care in a major metro costs far more than part-time after-school help in a small town. Post your range in the job ad: it filters for fit fast.

Should I do a trial day with a nanny candidate?

Yes, and pay for it. A half day with you home but hands-off shows you more than three interviews: how she handles crying, boredom, and your child's actual temperament. Pay her normal hourly rate. Candidates who refuse a trial are telling you something.

How do I fire a nanny if it is not working?

Use the terms in your written agreement: give the notice period you both signed, pay all final wages on time, and be direct but kind in person, not by text. Have backup care lined up before the conversation. Most bad fits surface during the trial period, which is exactly what the trial period is for.

What taxes do I owe when I hire a nanny?

In the U.S., hiring a household employee generally makes you a household employer: you withhold and pay Social Security and Medicare taxes, and may owe federal and state unemployment tax. The details depend on pay thresholds that change yearly, so check IRS Publication 926 or a payroll service.